Immigration: Alabama and Violations of the U.S. Constitution

Human Rights Watch accuses Alabama of violating constitution

Human Rights Watch says law HB56 breaches legal rights that apply to anyone regardless of their origin

Ed Pilkington New York

guardian.co.uk, Wednesday 14 December 2011 00.01 EST

[Human Rights Watch] ...recorded evidence of several cases of unauthorised immigrants who had wages withheld by employers and felt they were unable to take their grievance to court because of the new provision. One man, Alejandro, sought the advice of a lawyer but was told tha because of the new law he could not use the courts to retrieve the wages.

Human Rights Watch said this sent a clear message to employers that they did not need to fear legal redress from employees they had abused. That, the watchdog has pointed out, is a clear breach both of the US constitution and of international law.

In both the constitution and the international covenant on civil and political rights, all individuals must be treated equally before the law irrespective of their status. The 14th amendment of the US constitution says that no state shall "deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws".

Other aspects of HB56 have started to disturb the sacrosanct relationship between lawyer and client. Human Rights Watch said it had been told some lawyers were questioning whether they had a duty to inform on their clients should they lack proper papers....link to complete article

Related Guardian articles:

• 11 Oct 2011
  Alabama parents prepare for the worst: separation from their kids
• 7 Oct 2011
  Sweet home Alabama no more
• 7 Feb 2010
  Australian and US prosecutors clash over retrial of scuba death man
• 27 Apr 2010
  'This is Alabama, we speak English'